VW T4 Forum - VW T5 Forum banner

Are T4's money pits or a good buy?

1 reading
31K views 36 replies 28 participants last post by  Philshoz  
#1 ·
Hi everyone, I'm looking to buy a transporter but on a budget of about 5k. I am after a 5 seater so I can go on holiday with the family and a t4 seems to be all I can afford. As they are older vans now, are they expensive to own and run? I get the impression that it's a constant stream of little things that go wrong with them, meaning they are expensive to maintain as they need bits doing to them fairly often. Is this right or am I talking nonsense? Ideally I would get a t5 but they're ridiculously expensive unless they've travelled to the moon and back already.

Could anyone give me some advice please as I have no experience of transporters apart from really wanting one

Thanks

Noob
 
#3 ·
I think it's the same as everything mate. Luck of the draw. Sometimes you can land on a bad one. If you buy right you can avoid a lot of problems. Usual stuff applies, get the best van you can for your budget, look for a good service history, although both my T4's have had limited history. Budget to have the cam belt and water pump changed if it's not already been done and give it a good service when you get it. T4's aren't without problems but most of them are common niggles that are easy or cheap to repair. T5's on the other hand are different. I've had 2 in the past. First one was fine but the second one cost me over a grand to replace a wheel bearing and suspension arm, then over ÂŁ1500 not long after to repair the gearbox and replace the DMF and clutch. Touch wood so far the biggest job I've done on my T4's has probably been around ÂŁ200 replacing the exhaust.
Good luck with the hunt. Should land a decent T4 with that amount of money. T:
 
#4 ·
Hi to you.

They can be up to 25 years old now, so anything of that age will not be 'brand new' ............ you pays your money and you take your chance as they say.

1.9D is less complex and less expansive to maintain, 2.5TDI likes a lot of love and attention. I have had 3 brand new (1.9's) and an almost new one (2.5TDI) which I bought over 17 years ago (my ownership spans 25 years), probably spent more that I would like to admit, but T4's can becomes a passion ;)

Like anything if you really want it, just buy the best one you can afford; and read lots on the forum T:T:
 
#7 ·
These are wise words ?? If you are buying a 20 year old vehicle that has been on the road for that 20 years, then it is going to need some parts replacing. There will always be jobs that need doing, just use decent quality parts OE where possible and in some areas a must.
 
#8 ·
I've had a 2.5TDi 102 for two years now. Hardly any rust at all. The previous owner had loved it and looked after it, so they said. I believed them then and I still do. It had 150,000mls on it when I bought it. Immediately I had to replace rear springs (1 broken), 4 shocks (all knackered originals), all front bushes. To be on the safe side I replaced the coolant, brake fluid, engine oil, gear box oil, all filters. I've also done pads and discs all round. It had been little used and I found that the tyres were flat spotted from just sitting too long so I put new rubber all round as well. Oh yeah, I had a leak around windscreen, so as it was chipped I got that replaced as well.

So my initial 7.8K became about 10K. Thing is, it's a well sorted van now with little more to do (prob need a new clutch and flywheel in the next 15,000mls, another 1K).

You have to buy the best you can afford, but at 5K with 150,000 to 200,000mls on it you have to expect to pay out more when you've got it.

You won't get a decent T5 for 5K, so my personal view is forget that. I think T4 prices seem to have stalled at the moment, so that may be the best way to go. Final thoughts:
  1. Buy the best you can afford, especially body wise. Mechanical stuff can be replaced, but body work can be expensive.
  2. Remember you need to buy the best vehicle, you can turn it into a camper yourself, if you have the skills.
  3. To achieve your criteria you don't have to buy a T4/T5, or even a VW (tin hat time!).
  4. I don't think that they are any more a money pit than anything else, but you will be buying an old vehicle so .........
  5. Don't buy the first one you see, you must see a few and crawl all over them.


Which is a lot of words just to say if you get a good one it'll be err...., a good one :)
 
#9 ·
Hi mate. I desperately wanted a T4 over a T5, I even drove them back to back. I will say that the T5 was better in a fair few ways but I liked the look and the fixability of the T4 and to be honest I followed my heart. I looked at a few sheds and politely smiled and walked away all the time thinking of just buying a nice T5 through dissapointment as I had a more than appropriate budget but i kept going. In the end I bought a 2.5TDI on an 02 plate and spent a fair few quid having the engine, interior and minor bodywork patches sorted out.
It came in under what I woud have spent on a T5 and I have a sorted (in my opinion) camper that is a daily driver, fishing gear lugger, kid entertainer and holiday/leisure vehicle when required.
All I can say is if you are gonna do it do your homework, the guys on here helped me no end and really know their stuff.
Having said that you will do what your heart tells you I imagine, I did and dont regret it for a moment.
The mechanic where I have my van work done is selling his T4. I know its an earlier 1.9, has a nice interior and has been looked after as im sure you can imagine. Its well within your budget and I know he is eager to sell as he has already bought a Caddy. Nothing in it for me at all, just trying to do someone a good turn as others have done for me. He is just off the M2/M20 and M25 in Kent. I think it would make a great start for a project van or just a great little van as it is. Message me if its of any help to you.

All the best

Pat
 
#10 ·
My answer to this question is both.

If you get a straight and well serviced T4 and do nothing to it other than keeping up with the maintenance regime it will last a long time and serve you well.

BUT

T4's are getting old now so you may need to factor in bodywork at some point thanks to some pretty poor design issues such as the front arches and wings.

Lastly, and this is the big one. With T4 ownership comes and urge to fiddle and create a van that either makes some kind of statement or perhaps full fills a use as a camper, van for bikes, day van whatever.

All of a sudden the bills will begin to grow. I've seen budget campers, many good one's but people are still spending money on them in some form or other.

The only way round it is buying a pre converted and refurbed van with full service history that perfectly fits your needs. That is a very rare beast in my opinion.

This is actually one of the reasons why I've stayed away from T5's. \\\\\I'd basically be starting again and the bills would actually be bigger thanks to increased scene tax on that front.
 
#12 ·
I'm with The-Fozzer .......... T4's all the way T:


Doesn't anybody buy vehicles nowday's purely for the look of them ? I've always liked the design of the T4, great looking van compared to any other van available since it's conception to the present. The T5 is an ugly duckling which ever way you look at it. Personally I don't care what's under the skin, modern engines can go on for ever these days if well maintained.

I would also like to mention that there is no such thing as 'free motoring', as that's what your original post implies ......... budget of five grand and don't want to spend anymore. What ever used vehicle you buy you will have expenses, twenty year old vehicles will have rust on them no matter which make, some vehicles even rust within five years !

I bought a 2003 2.5 TDi in 2006 with only 48,000 miles on it ......... no rust on it at all ! but I was lucky, the previous owner was a T4 enthusiast and it got pampered Rasp:

Seek and ye shall find.





TURK
 
#14 ·
Already ! :eek: seems as though the manufacturers nowdays just keep on cutting corners, very very light 'mists' of paint on every body panel, saves billions in production costs. What isn't painted is plastic, plastic everywhere !


Back in the day, when cars were designed by men and not computers. 1990 original T4 concept designed by people with emotions, designers that had a feeling for what they were doing. That's partly why vehicles of today all look the same, designed by machines, built by robots. And you can always trust a machine to screw things up ! >>

Image



In all honesty, I quite like the look of this ......... Concept based on a T6 TriStar, Syncro version on the cards maybe ?
The interior is absolutely awful though, looks like Liberace front room ! >>

Image




I may have to wait a while before I can pick up a second hand one though LOL:







TURK
 
#15 ·


I know its tiny. But thats rust right there.

Sorry op not filling you with confidence in Vdubs. Just goes to show everything rusts especially 20 year old things.

Fact is its not something to half heartedly go at if you want something unique or head turning.. its going to hurt the wallet, and probly never come back to your wallet either if and when you sell it.

That syncro looks sweet turk, bet that hurts the wallet even more! I wonder if theres a T6 facelift concept yet..?
 
#16 ·
if you want something economical to do the job (rather than "unique or head turning") reckon T4s are a good bet all round. one thing we've found is the paintwork is good & assume original on ours.
had little trouble with ours, but 1.9td (no ecu), fairly basic engine (& powerful enough for us as a full camper) so repairs cheaper than many, minimum elec modern effort-savers to go wrong.
love it to bits, our first diesel & van, but we hardly spend anything on mods, just use it.
but it's the actual van that you get that's the crux. like any can only check one out as much as possible & then hope you're lucky. we were, even though we did it all wrong. ask the owners of any you see for a better insight & whether it might suit you, might even be for sale or know of one that is & reckon can be a better bet than other outlets.
just be aware that unlike a car you can adapt a van to quite an extent to suit your needs, many on here have, which might be different to what you think now. ensure your other half is of similar mind.
 
#18 ·
It all depends. If you are looking for a standard van and you get one with a good service history, it will cost no more than a car of a similar age.
But if you want to do something special, sky's the limit !!

I took a standard van - I paid ÂŁ1500 for a great T4 that a mate had owned and had serviced religiously- and then spent another ÂŁ5k having it resprayed and converted and that was with me doing most of the work myself !!

But at the end of the day it was worth a lot more than I'd paid out so is that a money pit?

Biggest problem these days is that a good unmodified well serviced van is hard to find unless you are prepared to part with a lot of dosh.
 
#19 ·
The Silver Bullet is a 2000 2.5TDI and has just racked up 305K miles on a 780 mile round trip from Burnley to Newquay and back absolutely no issues.

I paid ÂŁ4500 for it a little over two years ago. In that time I've spent the following on essential maintenance -

ÂŁ550 - timing belt and waterpump fitted by independent specialist (previous owner had no proof of it being done)
ÂŁ65 - new radiator (sprung a leak)
ÂŁ55 - oil change and oil filter (routine)
ÂŁ100 - replacement rear springs (both snapped)
ÂŁ89 - braided brake lines (originals perished)
ÂŁ12 - handbrake cable (snapped)
ÂŁ25 - new front brake pads (routine)
ÂŁ7 - replacement rear dummy fog light (dropped out and run over...)
ÂŁ32 - track rod ends (routine)
ÂŁ110 - power steering pump (worn out squealing bearings)

So in the time I've owned it it's cost me just over ÂŁ37 per month in essential maintenance, which for my money isn't too bad and it's far from a money pit. That said, the previous owner had looked after it very well.
 
#21 ·
I bought my T4 last May with around 160k miles, seemed to be in good condition and worth the ÂŁ4k it cost. Less than three months later the cambelt went (even though it was changed not long before!) and it cost me ÂŁ1100 to have a new cylinder head. At the time I was pretty peed off about it, but not so much now. The car that I had before the T4 was depreciating about ÂŁ1000 a year, so as long as the T4 doesn't need a new cylinder head every year it'll save me money in the long run LOL:
 
#22 ·
Just been reading about your exploits on your other thread Cuffbertt, you were doing so well .......... and then BANG !!! feel for you mate :( just goes to show, that what ever T4 people decide to buy, your first obligation is to get that cam belt and water pump checked and maybe replaced, even if the previous owner says it only recently got done. Way too many back street grease monkeys willing to give it a go !

A big investment at the time of taking ownership is an absolute must in my opinion, as I did. Cam-belt & water pump, and maybe brakes. Then you're good for another 80,000 miles or the next 4 years ( which ever comes first ).


Oh, btw ........ over here in France it's usually a custom to christen your vehicle with a female member' name in your family ( as vehicles are 'she's, like boats and ships ), be it your mother, gran, aunt ....... anyway, you get the drift I: Luckily for me my mothers name is 'Lucette', ........ so I named my baby 'Lulu' ! :D as the French tend to have shorted nicknames for members of their family.





TURK
 
#25 ·
Just been reading about your exploits on your other thread Cuffbertt, you were doing so well .......... and then BANG !!! feel for you mate :( just goes to show, that what ever T4 people decide to buy, your first obligation is to get that cam belt and water pump checked and maybe replaced, even if the previous owner says it only recently got done. Way too many back street grease monkeys willing to give it a go !

A big investment at the time of taking ownership is an absolute must in my opinion, as I did. Cam-belt & water pump, and maybe brakes. Then you're good for another 80,000 miles or the next 4 years ( which ever comes first ).


Oh, btw ........ over here in France it's usually a custom to christen your vehicle with a female member' name in your family ( as vehicles are 'she's, like boats and ships ), be it your mother, gran, aunt ....... anyway, you get the drift I: Luckily for me my mothers name is 'Lucette', ........ so I named my baby 'Lulu' ! :D as the French tend to have shorted nicknames for members of their family.
TURK
When I was looking for a van I looked out for one that had it's cambelt done recently, and the one I ended up buying actually had all the receipts from a garage showing it had been about 6 months before or so. After it blew up I was speaking to my mechanic who said that the garage who did it did a terrible job and didn't do something up properly (don't ask what though, as I have no idea!). The cambelt itself was fine but it just came off.

Ha I like the idea of naming it after a family member, but I'm not sure it would suit any of those names! I'm trying to think of female name that suits the van, so something that sounds like it can be a bit grumpy and give me some grief sometimes! :D
 
#23 ·
The newest vehicle I own was built in 1997. As was my T4.
I have another car of 1990 vintage.

Although none have aircon, a fact Mrs T reminded me of yesterday as we sweated back from Heathrow. She's simply been spoilt wafting round Canada in big modern rentals for 2 weeks. Aircon - pfft. One more thing to go wrong.

I'm a firm believer in investing in maintenance as opposed to losing in depreciation.

And don't get me started on the environmental cost of producing new vehicles!
 
#24 ·
Couldn't agree more. I've vowed and declared that I'll never own a vehicle which was built after 2004. The newest one I've ever owned is my Golf which is a 2003 GTI. I find that most mass-produced modern cars have absolutely no soul, character or passion in them. Plus as you say, way too many gadgets and gubbins to go wrong.
 
#26 · (Edited)
You spend a bit more money on maintenance, keeping an old vehicle on the road, instead of losing money in depreciation, on a new vehicle.

But I do both as I have the T4 and a 2010 Honda Jazz. 1.4EX i-vtec

The Jazz never goes wrong so just has servicing, MOT, tax etc but is going down in value and the T4 needs a bit of TLC but is going up in value. (you need to buy the right T4 at the right price)

I would recommend either or both vehicles to anyone.
 
#27 ·
One day I will add up all the receipts for my current T4; number four of the four I have owned, over a 25 year period. I have never done this, as the shock may kill me.

It's been 100% ABSOLUTE same VW Van Centre FULL service history for the 17 plus years I have owned it. The PDI, and first three services were carried out by VWUK where it was the UK re-launch vehicle way back in 1998; before I purchased it from them.

I feel the total would exceed what I paid for it; and buy a very special vehicle today .................. but who cares, certainly not me.

I have probably experienced just about every T4 fault there is, often more than once. If I felt there was something so much better than my Multivan, I would have bought it years ago ................... I was first on the list at my dealers for a Microbus back in 2001, but sadly that never happened, so 15 years later I still have a T4 LOL:LOL:LOL:
 
#29 ·
well I just sold my1999 t4 high top camper for ÂŁ10300.00, after 2 years of owning her. Actually went to Ireland for her, [ 1.9d]. Lady who owned her lost her licence and was unable to drive until 2019....God know what she did? Paid ÂŁ7k for her. hard bargaining...and drove her back. . you can make a profit.....
so I have now bought a 2.4d, high top 2001. Paid 14k , has air con fitted, [ bill for 2k for that] thankfully not me....46k on clock. top of the range spec, Shower, toilet heating hot and cold water. all mod cons......cam belt changed 6k miles ago, but 4 years, so booked in for next few weeks for this to be done.
Both slow but who cares when your in a camper....